60D RAW video - it's working !!!

Started by marekk, May 24, 2013, 09:27:26 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

marekk

https://vimeo.com/67453454

Test video shot with lv_af_raw, 1600x704 resized to 1280x544..
In each clip there was a one broken frame (with a lot of magenta) ~1 second from start.

I will try to test without lv_af_raw, it enables edge detection, maybe it's to much for cpu.

OrionnebelGalaxie17






My first "nature documentary" with raw video (Time Lapse in the forest) https://vimeo.com/67452326  :)

tin2tin

Quote from: marekk on June 01, 2013, 01:20:32 PM
I will try to test without lv_af_raw, it enables edge detection, maybe it's to much for cpu.
Does the camera load the module without crashing for you?

marekk

Yes, it works. Replace all files in modules directory, incl. magic.sym

Quote from: tin2tin on June 01, 2013, 03:20:11 PM
Does the camera load the module without crashing for you?

alestemple

Working fine!  ;)

Test video without color correction:

| Canon EOS 60D | Sigma 50mm f/2.8 MACRO | Canon EF-S 17-85 mm f/4-5,6 USM  |

| Twitter | YouTube |

tomnewmann

Quote from: marekk on June 01, 2013, 01:20:32 PM
https://vimeo.com/67453454

Test video shot with lv_af_raw, 1600x704 resized to 1280x544..
In each clip there was a one broken frame (with a lot of magenta) ~1 second from start.

I will try to test without lv_af_raw, it enables edge detection, maybe it's to much for cpu.

Same here. I am getting couple "magenda" frames on my footage.

31/05/13 build with lv_af_raw, 1280×720, SanDisk Extreme 32gb 45ms/s


NickRamey

Quote from: tomnewmann on June 01, 2013, 06:19:19 PM
Same here. I am getting couple "magenda" frames on my footage.

31/05/13 build with lv_af_raw, 1280×720, SanDisk Extreme 32gb 45ms/s



I ONLY CAN GET A BLACK AND WHITE FUZZY SCREEN! What do I do??

Teo Lee

I have a Sandisk(Class 10) 32GB 95MB/s and two Sandisk(Class 10) 8GB 30MB/s.
All the memory cards showed me this message "Movie Recording Has Stopped Automatically" when I shot about 5 second.
Is there anybody who has same problem with me?

CarVac

What resolution and framerate are you shooting at?

960x540 at 24fps works on most decently fast cards.

Teo Lee

The resolution and framerate were 1728x736 and 24fps.   :D

CarVac

When adjusting the framerate, it should say along the bottom of the screen what the write speed will be. Keep it under 20, and it'll probably be fine.

My Transcend 16 gig class 10 works at 960x540 24, as I said before. It benchmarks at 20 MB/s.

vovaja

sorry for the stupid question. I have a 60d. anymore have guarantee. is it possible to physically increase the buffer in my camera?
canon 60D, hellios-44-2,canon 28-135mm

CarVac

Quote from: vovaja on June 02, 2013, 11:59:47 AM
sorry for the stupid question. I have a 60d. anymore have guarantee. is it possible to physically increase the buffer in my camera?

No.

kotik

Quote from: vroem on June 01, 2013, 12:10:27 PM
I was just saying that comparing 14-bit RAW with 8-bit RGB is like comparing apples and oranges.

It's more like different tastes between apples.
8-bit RGB means that each pixel has a bit-depth of 8 bits , giving a range from 0-255 for each channel,
and a total RGB color depth of 16777216.
14-bit RAW obviously has a wider color gamut and image and metadata are seperated.
My first Canon: FTb QL (Quick Loading), my first digital Canon: 20D 2.0.3
The current one: Canon EOS R

kotik

Nightly build 2-6-2013 plus update #6 -without LV_AF_RAW:

960 x 480 @25FPS

Does work as long as I stop recording manually.
If the buffer overruns at 14xx frames the RAW's cannot be processed.
My first Canon: FTb QL (Quick Loading), my first digital Canon: 20D 2.0.3
The current one: Canon EOS R

Nang

Hello all,

sorry for being a noob and slightly off topic... I currently have ML v2.3 installed. Do I need to reformat my cards and set my camera back to factory before installing the nightly builds?

Thanks
Portfolio: somnang.4ormat.com | Video: https://vimeo.com/somnang
Prime: Olympus Zuiko OM 24mm f/2.8 | Rokinon Cine 85mm T/1.5 | Pentax SMC Takumar 50mm f/1.4 | Helios 44-2 58mm f/2.0 | Jupiter 37A 135mm f/3.5
Zoom: Meteor 5-1 17-69mm f/1.9, Sigma 18-35mm f/1.8, Tamron 24-70mm Di VC f/2.

saeed2vfx

Quote from: Nang on June 02, 2013, 05:48:29 PM
Hello all,

sorry for being a noob and slightly off topic... I currently have ML v2.3 installed. Do I need to reformat my cards and set my camera back to factory before installing the nightly builds?

Thanks

No, Just replace autoexec.bin in root folder and place "modules" in ML folder.

Nang

Quote from: saeed2vfx on June 02, 2013, 06:06:09 PM
No, Just replace autoexec.bin in root folder and place "modules" in ML folder.

Awesome!! Thanks so much!!
Portfolio: somnang.4ormat.com | Video: https://vimeo.com/somnang
Prime: Olympus Zuiko OM 24mm f/2.8 | Rokinon Cine 85mm T/1.5 | Pentax SMC Takumar 50mm f/1.4 | Helios 44-2 58mm f/2.0 | Jupiter 37A 135mm f/3.5
Zoom: Meteor 5-1 17-69mm f/1.9, Sigma 18-35mm f/1.8, Tamron 24-70mm Di VC f/2.

Bioskop.Inc

This question is for any developers that might read this:

Is it possible to get some different ratios, as the jump from (16:9) 960x544 to 1280x720 is huge!
With 960x544 i'm getting a steady 7680 frames or 5mins recording (1280x720 is only 350frames/15secs), so a bit bigger ratio might mean better quality & actuality reaching minutes of recording (1,2,3,4...) instead of seconds.

Also, the Mb/s shown whilst recording is all at a steady 19.6, even for 960x544 & for this it used to be 20.1Mb/s -so what's happened here?

kotik

Quote from: Bioskop.Inc on June 02, 2013, 10:09:11 PM
This question is for any developers that might read this:

Is it possible to get some different ratios, as the jump from (16:9) 960x544 to 1280x720 is huge!
With 960x544 i'm getting a steady 7680 frames or 5mins recording (1280x720 is only 350frames/15secs), so a bit bigger ratio might mean better quality & actuality reaching minutes of recording (1,2,3,4...) instead of seconds.

Also, the Mb/s shown whilst recording is all at a steady 19.6, even for 960x544 & for this it used to be 20.1Mb/s -so what's happened here?

If I try 960 x 544 @ 24 FPS or @24FPS the maximum frame count is just over 1400.
Using a Sandisk Extreme Pro SD card (32GB/95MB/s).

Do you use special settings/tweaks?
My first Canon: FTb QL (Quick Loading), my first digital Canon: 20D 2.0.3
The current one: Canon EOS R

QUATRO

What I've noticed when working with RAW footage in After Effects is that AE treats the DNG's as proper RAW files even in 8BPC comps, meaning that any levels or curves adjustments actually work as exposure adjustments (say if I darken up the footage - the highlights don't become grey and the darker parts of the image darken up before the lighter ones, if this makes sense) as opposed to a linear degradation in colors when working with actual 8-Bit footage (unless of course HDR Highlight Compressor is used on the RAW or something). That is really neat for precise CC and grading.

And just for those not-so-tech-geeks out there:
8-bit Per Channel color means Red Green and Blue (and Alpha if present) values are described in 8 bits of information per pixel in each channel (32bits total RGB), which is 256 values (0-255, just as we are used to).
14-bit Per Channel DNG frames that we get here should in theory hold up to 16384 values per pixel in each channel, which is 64 times more data than the 8BPC color space.
Pros of RAW video? 4:4:4 color sampling + exposure adjustments for detail recovery = fucking awesome!
:)

Bioskop.Inc

Quote from: kotik on June 03, 2013, 12:24:54 AM
If I try 960 x 544 @ 24 FPS or @24FPS the maximum frame count is just over 1400.
Using a Sandisk Extreme Pro SD card (32GB/95MB/s).

Do you use special settings/tweaks?


I'm using a Sandisk Extreme Pro SDHC 1 (8gb 45MB/s).
I turn everything off in ML as well as Global Draw.
Also, if you don't set FPS Override it will record @ 23.976 natively (I only set FPS Override @ 24 when using x5 Zoom).

Also, there are different versions of the 60D & by that i mean the older ones made circa 2011 behave differently to the newer versions - no one knows why or what has changed in the manufacture of the 60D.
I use a 60D from 2011 & seem to get more Frames.

kotik

Quote from: Bioskop.Inc on June 03, 2013, 12:08:42 PM
Also, there are different versions of the 60D & by that i mean the older ones made circa 2011 behave differently to the newer versions - no one knows why or what has changed in the manufacture of the 60D.
I use a 60D from 2011 & seem to get more Frames.

Weird, I did buy my 60D also in november 2011!
My first Canon: FTb QL (Quick Loading), my first digital Canon: 20D 2.0.3
The current one: Canon EOS R

Bioskop.Inc

Quote from: kotik on June 03, 2013, 04:21:59 PM
Weird, I did buy my 60D also in november 2011!

Hmmm Strange!
I got mine in April 2011.
Perhaps it might be region specific & no one has really investigated any further than there seems to be a marked difference between people's 60Ds.

Try a different SD card & see what results you get.
Also, i'm getting best results in 16:9 & also 2.35:1.

theollybanks

I've been messing around with this amazing new feature of Magic Lantern, the upscales from 1280x720 are just stunning, take H.264 and bin it! Not literally obviously it still has its uses...

Obviously the detailing in the comparison shot's are out of this world, a quick word on my setup:
Canon 60D (Purchased in 2012)
SanDisk 16GB Extreme 45mb/s
Pentax Super-Takumar 50 mm F/1.4
1280x720 RAW_REC
RAW2DNG to After Effects, Graded & Sharpened by a factor of 50

I used FilmConvert Pro, and selected the gamma profile "Canon Generic Technicolor" although I know the picture profile has no impact on the RAW_REC output it seemed to yield a much nicer grade in FilmConvert!



(EDIT:My critical focus point on the comparison was the brown leaf in centre frame and I was stopped down on the Pentax to f/2.8)