Avoid using lens correction in ACR and resolve

Started by mannfilm, August 27, 2014, 08:27:38 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

mannfilm

Lens correction in ACR or resolve changes every pixel. (Its basically the transform or Distort tool.) Still photographers have been avoiding it for years. They claim it kills the perceived resolution and the quality of the image.  Can also introduce video artifacts, including moire. As a ACR function, it is not designed for video, but for stand alone photographs, so the "correction" can easily vary from frame to frame.

Walter Schulz

Thanks, but are there any examples showing such effects?
I'm a still photographer and I'm not avoiding lens correction that much.

DFM

Lens correction is a geometrical transform based entirely on fixed profile data - it is not adaptive.

jimmyD30

I use lens correction for video in ACR and I can tell it's never varied from frame to frame.

Rodrigo Riedel

I agree, it's worked perfectly for me all the time

ChadMuffin

I have been using it most of the time. I haven't noticed any variations of distortion or moire in ACR. While it can be argued that lens corrections, fixing distortion that comes with a given lens, can ruin that lens look. But, you may not always want that. Trying to keep color correction, or just making sure each shot doesn't vary too much between shots can make lens corrections useful depending on how you are shooting. Same thing with vignetting.. I'm looking at you Canon 50mm f1.4.

hateom

Same here, I've been using it for a long time. I agree with the second argument - it can decrease the resolution, especially on a footage shot with wide angle lenses when a barrel distortion is significant.