I know the live view can't always be trusted 100%, but this is such a dramatic difference that you would think it is not capturing the same settings that the live view is displaying (even though the log says everything is correct). It has happened quite a few times for me where my live view does not change when I change my settings (for example, I can go to f-22 in slightly dim indoor lighting and it looks the same in live view as f-2.8 because my live view doesn't change to reflect my settings for some reason), and I'm wondering if something's just really off. I will try using the same settings but with my T3i instead of my T2i the next time I shoot (Monday) and see if there is a difference. Thanks for the advice.